What a Governor Actually Controls
Campaigns promise things that sit with a legislature, a court, or a federal agency. The office has real power, and it is somewhere else.
Gubernatorial campaigns are fought over subjects a governor cannot unilaterally change, which produces a predictable cycle of promises, disappointment, and the conclusion that the winner was insincere.
Usually they were not. The office simply has a different shape than the campaign implied. Three levers do most of the work, and none of them makes a good slogan.
The first is appointments. A governor fills judgeships, agency leadership, commission seats, and university boards, and those choices outlast the term. The second is the budget, particularly the ability to propose a framework and to veto items within it. The third is enforcement discretion, which determines how vigorously existing law is applied and against whom.
None of these appear in the debates, because each requires explaining a mechanism rather than naming a goal. The result is that voters evaluate governors on outcomes the office does not control while the decisions it does control go unexamined for four years.
Miriam Halloway writes for The 13th Bell on politics. This piece was edited and fact checked before publication.
Get The 13th Bell in your inbox
